Road networks, tunnels, airports, etc.
are always the talk of the town in Nepal. You just need to travel to a nearby
district and people will be telling you that “road is being proposed so that is
going to affect so and so aspects”. Similarly, Kathmandu-Terai fast track is
another dream that has been woven by our policy makers. After every lofted annunciation
there lies the challenges of implementation. That is where my interest is focused. The Government has recently offered the project to the Nepal
Army. The highlights of the project are:
| click to enlarge |
I do not want to put forward an
argument for or against BOOT model or any other PPP or non-PPP model for that matter. Google
and you shall find charts, papers, risk matrix, etc. for all arguments around
but few project specific things that I wonder and ponder here:
1. Fast Track - Second International
Airport relationship
The Fast Track proposed is estimated
to decrease the travel of around 200 kms but the question remains whether the
work for the Second International Airport will follow the pace of the Fast
Track for the maximum utilization and infrastructural increment to the
nation. The use of the fast track is said to be complimentary with the
Second International Airport. But the question arises how many “second”
international airports are we going to have? – Lumbini, Pokhara?? Where else?
2. Project Overview and Quality
Assurance
The army will be forming its own
review committee for project overview. But can it maintain an independent
outlook on the project implementation and quality. The government should create
a Project Monitoring Mechanism so that the quality and road safety standards of the project is
maintained.
3. Cost and Time Overruns
Most of the construction work will be done by the Nepal Army so it will be a tricky situation because
no matter what you assume Nepal Army is a government entity so what happens when
there are cost and time overruns? Is the government going to have a performance
contract? Who will be liable? Could the government have an upper hand if the
project is awarded to a private player where it can dictate the performance?
4. Social and Environment Issues
Although Nepal Army has proven a good national servant in terms of the road construction work but the DNA of the institution may not be in line with construction and development of complex infrastructure projects. Nepal Army maintains a command and control style of management which is required for a security agency as such but that approach may not be appropriate for building of infrastructure projects. And just because it has been a competent agency does not mean that all activities should be awarded to them. In Nepali as they say – “Dang Dung
garni”, are we going to be building our infrastructure with that approach? The
army is ill-equipped to handle sensitive social issues and maintain highest
international standards. There might be push back on this from Nepal Army but
we know the truth on the ground. We all might be for development but without
proper tackling of social and environmental issues it won’t be a success. Army
mentality may not be appropriate for that.
No comments:
Post a Comment