All throughout my university days, a frequent word always popped up "first mover advantage". It seemed all but a closed case that whenever someone moved in first they would indeed have some kind of an advantage in that sector or market. But this I feel hasn't applied to the developers of Upper Karnali (900 MW) and Arun 3 (900MW) Hydropower projects. Government of Nepal represented by the Office of Investment Board and the developers signed the Project Development Agreement ( Concession Agreement ) on 19th September 2014 ( Upper Karnali) and 25th November 2014 ( Arun-3 ). The deals were first of a kind for Nepal and was met with much fan fare. But its been over 2 years since those deals have been signed but both projects haven't completed financial close. I am not here to dwell with what were the detailed reasons behind the delay. My view point stems from my experience as the Project Manager of Arun-3 Project from the government's side. My role encompasses managing all the obligations of the government and helping the project reach financial close.
The first mover problems came even before the document was finalized. The new nature of the Investment Board meant that it wasn't enough for these projects to be passed by the board. They had to be passed by the cabinet as well. It might seem ridiculous to approve the same document by the same group of people at two different Government mechanisms but more ridiculous was that the proposal for it to be approved had to be taken by Ministry of Energy , not the Investment Board. Recently, Ministry of Energy finished a similar document - PDA with Upper Trishuli and it was much easier for them to take it for approval.
Old license regime of survey license and generation license fell apart under the PDA approach. The questions were raised as to who and how will the license be provided. The Investment Board Act did empower the office of the Investment Board to provide the licenses but opinions were divided. This issue is still not solved , Ministry of Forest is still asking for the generation license for the projects to approve clearance of trees. The concept that PDA provides necessary grants to the developers to do the necessary work haven't sinked in. Ultimately , as the forest clearance will be finalized for these projects this concept will be clear and procedures will be set in place for following projects like the Upper Trishuli 1. I am not saying that everything will be perfect for UT1 but they do have an understood procedure to follow.
Everyone with a "mind" in Nepal is questioning why these projects haven't had the necessary traction. But I am not sure that everyone has had to deal with the government on issues that don't have clear precedence. There are many examples of issues that have created ambiguity and run around for the developers. I wonder if they feel that because they were the first ones to come under the umbrella of the PDA within the Investment board that they have faced such unique hurdles.
So, What is the inference of all this. Do not be the first mover? No, I don't think so. My inference is two folds:
1. Whenever new deals are to be signed, extra care must be given on the facilitation. The government may have to go above and beyond for the first movers in Nepal and not treat developers with a regulator (policing approach) hat.
2. While the big ticket items on concession agreements might be very important but reverse engineering of the processes are as important for the timely execution of such projects. Clarity on each and every step is the need of the moment. There is a need to create as much clarity as possible.
If these are not taken care of then investors and developers will remain on the sidelines looking at each other to see who jumps in first and how the first movers fare. With the recent experience of Upper Karnali and Arun-3 , may be investors are wondering if being the first mover in Nepal is just a disadvantage.
(Views expressed are completely Private)
No comments:
Post a Comment